Osmium logoContact us
Back to Blog

How to Choose Between a Freelancer and an Agency: Key Criteria and Tips

Osmium
Author
Osmium
Published
April 21, 2025
Tags
    featured image

    Efficiency, budgeting and timeline — who is the better fit for you: a Freelancer or a Web Development Agency? To make a correct decision, it’s important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of both formats.

    Analyze the Future Product

    The scope of it will determine the desired type of collaboration.

    • Scale. Small to medium-sized projects (landing pages, corporate websites, or minor updates), one Developer can efficiently handle. For large-scale tasks (web platforms, SaaS solutions, or high-load services) an outside company is a better choice.
    • Budget. Freelancers for website development are often more cost-effective because they work alone. However, this may come with risks, such as delays. Agencies charge higher, but they offer full-cycle development, tech support, and adhere to SLA (Service Level Agreement) commitments.
    • Timeline. Single specialist are flexible, but their workload can be inconsistent, potentially leading to holdups. Development Teams adhere to defined due dates, with a Project Manager ensuring process coordination and risk mitigation.
    • Required Expertise. Separate workers typically specialize in certain technologies, such as Next.js, Shopify, or WebGL, making them ideal for focused tasks. Agencies consist of UX/UI Designers, QA Specialists, and DevOps Engineers, enabling them to conduct complex assignments.
    • Communication & Management. Dealing with a freelance employee involves hands-on oversight and frequent revisions. The team organizes the workflow using project management approach and strict deadlines.

    Option comparison based on your goals and understanding the basis of Freelancer vs Agency principles help go with suitable format.

    Make Decision Strategically

    Choosing between an independent Developer and a Company involves following steps.

    • Create a Technical Requirements Document. Define functional, technical, design standards, deadlines, budget, and potential risks. A well-prepared brief will set clear expectations.
    • Evaluate Portfolios and Reviews. Look for candidates with relevant experience in positions of similar complexity, and clear technical specification. View code samples and showcased recommendations. Also, check Clutch or GitHub for unbiased feedback.
    • Discuss Collaboration Terms. To prevent misunderstandings, agree on the responsibilities, budget, and time frame upfront, based on the pricing policies. Secure the partnership with a contract.

    These steps will build a solid foundation for successful work.

    Make Decision Strategically

    Optimize Collaboration

    For a productive partnership with a Software Development Services Agency or a Website Development Freelancer, structured workflow is essential.

    Establish Effective Communication using modern tools:

    • Slack, Discord – for real-time discussions and feedback;
    • Notion, Confluence – for documenting meetings alongside key conclusions;
    • JIRA, Trello, Asana – for task tracking.

    To coordinate one Developer, Slack and Trello are effective, but Teams rely on JIRA and Confluence. Weekly stand-ups and retrospectives after key milestones help keep the process on track. Maintain Quality Control, as regular observations help prevent issues in later stages. Key methods are code review, automated testing and performance testing.

    Since most Web & App Development Freelancers lack QA expertise, testing should be arranged separately. Agencies ensure consistent results with internal efficiency monitoring processes.

    Assess Flexibility and Scalability. If changes arise during work, evaluate their cost, alignment with the stated duties, overall impact on the final product. Implement adjustments that fit within the budget or significantly enhance the user experience to avoid unnecessary expenses and delays.

    Choose cautiously to balance performance, costs, and timelines. Rely on our selection criteria to consciously decide.